The CW Source

Bela from Supernatural: OK, we get that you had a rough life. The thievery we could overlook, but shooting Sam and siccing Gordon on the boys? Nothing but lumps of coal for you, young lady.

Lex from Smallville: Building an army of meteor-affected supersoldiers tends to be frowned upon in polite society. Unfortunately, Lex already has everything, so a lump of coal in his Christmas stocking isn't going to be much of a deterrent.

Lana from Smallville: This may not be popular, but we think Lana deserves to be on the bad-kids' list. Look, she took Lionel captive, tried to kill Lex, continues to lie to Clark, and is wearing an awful lot of black clothing. We know her motives are pure, but her methods… not so much.

Chuck from Gossip Girl: Chuck just oozes naughtiness -- that's what makes him so much fun to watch.

Bianca from America's Next Top Model: She sabotaged other players, sent Jenah in the wrong direction, and delighted in torturing Heather, Lisa, and anyone else who passed into her field of vision. She didn't win the competition – and she gets no presents from us.

Tyra Banks from America's Next Top Model: Oh, Tyra – we used to like you. But your drama-queen antics, your insistence on breaking down the women on your show, and your obviously rigged model winner this season makes you naughty in our eyes. We hope you make some changes next season!

All the men from The Game: Malik's a player who fired his mom. Jason's on steroids. Derwin is a cheating ass. These men are getting nothing but coal from Santa. Of course, with their NFL-star salaries, they can buy their own Christmas presents.

Nice because they're naughty!
These characters' irresistible naughty streaks keep us interested, even if we wouldn't necessarily trust them.

Dean from Supernatural: OK, so he's a good-time guy, but he's still heroic. Surely all the world-saving he does makes up for his more questionable habits? Besides, it's his naughty side that makes a lot of us love him so much!

Andrew from Life Is Wild: He skips out on chores, almost fails his classes, and nearly gets himself killed mountain climbing, but Andrew's far from rotten to the core. Remember when he covered for Oliver during the cheetah-shooting debacle? And his budding romance with Mbali definitely brings out the best in him. We're rooting for him to get in touch with his sweet side -- as long as he doesn't forget that his wild streak is what makes him so much fun.

The Devil on Reaper: You could never call the Devil nice, per se – but he sure is charming and a lot of fun to hang out with (when he's not torturing your immortal soul.) We can't help but love him, and figure Santa would feel the same way.

Blair Waldorf on Gossip Girl: Our favorite teen vixen does all sorts of things wrong (blackmailing, cheating, and encouraging break-ins -- and that's just for starters) but we wouldn't have it any other way.

Unclassifiable:
This pair of Sams leaves us scratching our heads -- they just don't fit into any category.

Sam from Supernatural: On the Nice side, he saves the world a lot, he's a good brother (usually), he's honest (usually) and kind, and he fights to save people from evil beasties. Unfortunately, he may be the Antichrist, which makes it difficult for us to wholeheartedly endorse him as nice. Plus, he does seem to be killing a lot of people and/or things lately…

Sam from Reaper: He's nice because he saves people from their doom and sends evil souls back to hell. But he's doing all this for the Devil, who is the Anti-Nice. It's enough to make Santa's head explode.