Wow. Kripke really likes torturing us, doesn't he? The Supernatural season ended with everyone betrayed -- by angels, by demons, and even by their own better instincts. They boys have learned they can't necessarily trust themselves -- but they can rely on each other. Now we've just got to hope we can rely on them to save the world from Armageddon. In the meantime, we'll be hiding in the closet, sniffling and feeling heartbroken for those poor, poor boys...
The boys went their separate ways last week, and they're still feeling the aftereffects. While Ruby tried to comfort Sam -- buck up, camper, you'll make up afterwards! -- Awesome Bobby awesomely tore Dean a new one, which was awesome. After Dean refused to call Sam to try to make up, BOBBY SMASH!
You stupid, stupid son of a bitch! Well boo-hoo, I'm so sorry your feelings are hurt, PRINCESS. Are you under the impression that family is supposed to make you feel GOOD? Bake you an apple pie, maybe? They're SUPPOSED to make you miserable, that's why they're family!....You sound like a whiny brat. No, you sound like your dad. Well let me tell you something. You dad was a coward. ... He'd rather push Sam away than reach out to him. Well that don't strike me as brave. You are a better man than your daddy ever was. So you do us both a favor: Don't be him.
See what we mean? Awesome.
Alas, that's the last we see of Bobby, because Dean is whisked away to a white-and-gold room, where Zachariah and Castiel are waiting to ply him with pleasures. Actually, Cass is silent, but Zachariah is positively effusive. He offers Dean beer, burgers, and the illicit pleasures of Ginger and Mary-Ann from Gilligan's Island. What he doesn't offer is answers, no matter how much Dean asks. Don’t you worry your pretty little head, he tells Dean -- we'll let you know when we need you.
Dean kills some time by leaving Sam a message:
I'm still pissed, and I owe you a serious beatdown, but... sigh.. I shouldn't have said what I said. I'm not dad. We're brothers, you know, we're family, and no matter how bad it gets, that doesn't change. Sammy I'm sorry.
But Sam just can't face listening to what Dean has to say -- what if it's bad? So instead, he goes along with Ruby, catching Lilith's "personal chef" and torturing Lilith's location out of her. She begs for death, and Sam is willing to oblige -- but Ruby says they'll need her for a blood borne power-boost when it comes time to fight Lilith. The demon is
pissed -- Sam promised! -- and she fights back the only way she knows how: She retreats into her host's brain, and lets the terrified, innocent human come out. Cindy McClellan begs Sam to help her, but he just throws her in the trunk of his car. He and Ruby listen to her scream and cry and beg all the way to Maryland.
They're heading to a ruined church where, in 1972, a priest went nuts and disemboweled eight nuns. The priest was possessed by Azazel -- Old Yellow Eyes himself -- and he was looking to release his "Daddy" -- Lucifer. The gate to the cage where Lucifer was imprisoned was right there, under the convent (or "nun factory," as Azazel calls it.) After slaughtering the nuns, Azazel learns what he has to do to release Lucifer: he needs Lilith -- and a child.
Meanwhile, Dean is getting increasingly antsy, wanting to find Sam. Finally, Zachariah appears and breaks the news: We want Lilith to break the seal. The apocalypse is just the final war between Heaven and Hell, and Zachariah and the "senior management" is convinced that Heaven can win. So bring it! Dean is important -- he's the one who will kill Lucifer. But he's not going to stop Lilith, and he's not going to talk to Sam. That's final. And where's God in all of this? "God? God has left the building," Zachariah says.
When Castiel comes to apologize, Dean lays into him. Castiel seems abashed, but unmoved, even after Dean punches him (Note: Punching an angel leads to a ringing sound and a seriously hurt hand.) But something Dean said got through, because Cass shows up later and makes the Angel-B-Gone sign with his own blood. (Yay! OUR Castiel is back!) He tells Dean that he has to stop Sam -- Lilith herself if the last seal. If Sam kills her, he opens the gate and Lucifer comes out. Then he takes Dean to the Prophet Chuck (who is ordering a whole lot of female companionship for his last night before the world ends) and finds out where Sam is. Castiel sends Dean along and stays with Chuck to face the Archangel. Will he survive? We don't know.
Sam is at a crossroads -- he needs to drain the nurse if he's going to be strong enough to take Lilith, but he doesn't want to suck blood from a screaming human, even if the demon is hiding inside her. He wonders if maybe Dean was right about this -- and he finally steels the courage to listen to Dean's voicemail. But it's not the message Dean left. Zachariah altered it to give Sam a little push. This is what Sam hears:
Listen to me, your bloodsucking freak! Dad always said I'd either have to save you or kill you. Well, I'm giving you fair warning: I'm done trying to save you. You're a monster Sam, a vampire. You're not you anymore. And there's no going back.
And since Sam has nothing left to go back to, he decides to jump into the breach. He drains the girl and goes after Lilith. Dean arrives just in time to see Sam and Ruby confront her, but Ruby slams the door before Dean can enter. Sam works his mojo... and then hears Dean screaming for him, and stops. Lilith laughs -- "You turned yourself into a freak, a monster, and now you're not going to bite? I'm sorry, but that is honestly adorable." And that's enough to tip the balance. Sam kills her. Her blood runs out and rings the floor. Sam stares, confused, as Ruby celebrates:
Ruby: I can't believe it. You did it.
Sam: What? What did I do?
Ruby:You opened the door, and how he's free at last!
SamI killed her!
Ruby:And it is written, that the first demon will be the last seal. And you busted her open, now guess who's coming to dinner.
Samoh my god.
Ruby:Guess again!
It gets worse: Sam accuses Ruby of poisoning him with her blood, but she denies it:
No, it wasn't the blood -- it was you, and your choices. I just gave you the options and you chose the right path every time. [Pause] You didn't need the feather to fly, you had it in you the whole time, Dumbo!
Dean finally bursts in and sees it's too late. At least he has time to kill Ruby -- and this time, Sam no only doesn't stop him, he holds Ruby while Dean stabs. Sam begs Dean to forgive him, and Dean begs Sammy to make a run for it. Light pours from the floor as the church rumbles and cracks. "Dean," Sam says, despairing, "He's coming."
And that's it, folks. Lucifer is, in fact, rising, and the boys made it possible -- Dean by breaking the first seal, and Sam by breaking the last. How will they live with that knowledge? And how will WE live with the wait until season five?